The Best Peanut Butter Cups You Can Buy, According to Candy Fanatics

Need a reminder that peanut butter cups aren’t just for kids? Pick up a pack (or two or three…) of Justin’s^® peanut butter cups.

These treats look straight out of the case at your favorite candy counter thanks to a small swirl of chocolate topping each cup. Biting into this confection, these candies have the satisfying snap of tempered chocolate—a quality only Justin’s had in this test. While marked as milk chocolate, our testers note that the coating here tasted somewhere between milk and dark chocolate—so these wouldn’t be ideal for dark chocolate-avoidant kiddos.

Inside this chocolate case, you’ll find a smooth peanut butter center that played perfectly with the nearly dark chocolate.

Another reason to love Justin’s: The brand’s candies are all USDA-certified organic, so you can feel good about indulging. And if peanut butter isn’t quite your thing, you can grab Justin’s^® almond butter or cashew butter cups for something a bit different.