Skip to content

The Best Halloween Candy According to Our Staff

The Washington Post

We might look like grown-ups, or some approximation thereof. We might even “adult” on a regular basis, comparing car-insurance rates, getting in our daily steps and chuckling at dad jokes. Some of us even raise other, smaller humans pretty well.But wave a bag of orange-and-black bagged Halloween candy in front of our noses, and we’ll regress to our childhood selves faster than you can scream “trick or treat!” There’s something primal about the bond formed with those prized bits of sugar back when the prospect of Halloween candy brought on the sensation of pure bliss instead of anxiety (did we remember to grab a bag at the grocery store? And how many steps equal a mini candy bar?).Here are our staff’s favorite candies, beloved even though we’re more likely these days to be buying them in bulk or filching from our kids’ stash (don’t tell!) than collecting in a plastic jack-o-lantern of our own.

Justin’s® Mini Milk Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

Peanut butter cups are the perfect candy. I built my Halloween obsession as a kid on Reese’s, of course, but as an adult I discovered Justin’s, which uses Rainforest Alliance certified chocolate (and sells varieties that include almond butter, white and dark chocolate). I switched teams, although I won’t pass up a Reese’s if somebody else is buying. My preferred size are minis because I just don’t want to eat an entire — oh, who am I kidding? Thankfully, these are foil-wrapped, because the foil forces me to take at least a few seconds of “rest” before I eat another one, thereby allowing me to indulge in the fantasy that I’m not actually gorging. It’s a trick and a treat, all in one. — Joe Yonan